Upstairs, the grand hall—lit by iconic arched windows and framed by ornamental turrets—served as a meeting place for the Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks. Downstairs, generations of storefronts and professional offices kept the building alive with commerce.
As the decades marched on, the ground floor evolved alongside the community's retail needs. By mid-century it had become a nostalgic, high-foot-traffic neighborhood anchor widely remembered by locals as Scott's 5 & Dime. After the Scott's era, the space briefly carried on as a regional TG&Y variety store, then took a final, short-lived run as a local discount dollar store before the doors closed for good.
J.P. continued investing across Block 37 and along Main Street, with interests that included the Haynes Brothers store, later Rephan’s Department Store, and the nearby Saenger Theatre. He later relocated to Hot Springs, yet remained closely tied to Hope and was laid to rest at Rose Hill Cemetery.